Most of the merchandise in Edmonton Transit Service's new online store is not made in Canada, the City of Edmonton has confirmed.
ETS launched its merch store on Nov. 12. It sells standard-fare merchandise like hoodies, shirts, a toque and a cap. Conspicuously absent from the site is any mention whatsoever of where products are sourced or manufactured.
The city confirms that source is not Canada.
When considering our partner for running the ETS Shop, it was determined SVS Marketing aligned best, as they are a Canadian company that provides a cost-effective approach to running the store. They also have experience running other transit agency merchandise stores, such as TTC (Toronto), Translink (Vancouver) and Metrolinx (Greater Toronto/Hamilton).
While most of the items are not manufactured in Canada, all items are designed in Canada.
None of the store's product pages lists a country of origin, and there's no "Made in Canada" claim anywhere on the site.
A store run from North York
The store's terms of use say ETSshop.ca is "solely operated and maintained by SVS Marketing," at 15 Densley Ave. in North York, Ontario. SVS also runs the merchandise stores for the TTC, TransLink and Metrolinx, which the city gave as one of the reasons it was picked.
The city says the store costs it nothing to run. The Edmonton Journal reports the city gets a percentage of the profits and expects about $50,000 a year.
Orders ship by Canada Post, and there is no local pickup. A $75 "Flying E" hoodie quotes $18.28 to ship to downtown Edmonton, with four-day delivery.
The same hoodie ships to downtown Toronto for $10.07, next day.
Six years in the making
-
2020
ETS first pitches selling transit merchandise. The pandemic stalls it, as ETS's Carrie Hotton-MacDonald later tells CBC.
-
2024
February: online merch shows up on the list of budget-cut ideas to raise money. Coun. Andrew Knack: "If that's an additional net $25,000 positive to the city, why wouldn't you do that?"
-
2025
March 25: the city posts RFP 939432, "Online Merchandising of Edmonton Transit Service (ETS) Branded Products." U.S. tariffs on Canadian goods took effect three weeks earlier.
-
2025
October 15: the RFP is cancelled.
-
2026
November 12: the store launches, run by SVS Marketing.
The RFP's public notice asked the contractor to set up and run the store, pick the products and source them. When the city put out the RFP, after the start of the trade war, it did not mention anything about Canadian manufacturing or local artists.
What ETS says
I reached out to Carrie Hotton-MacDonald, the ETS branch manager, expressing disappointment with this implementation. She replied promptly, despite being out of the office.
What we have rolled out so far is just a starting point. It was always positioned with Council as an online retail model, outsourced to reduce risk and operating costs. We talked about trying to keep it simple and aligned with how other large systems have done this. We administered an RFP process but didn't get any responses to it, which limited our options for how to proceed.
The offerings are just a starting point and will evolve to include more variety, and hopefully, partnerships with local artists. We are actively exploring options with our vendor partner and sharing feedback with them. For example, in terms of where the products are sourced from, we will share that feedback.
She added that ETS has heard a lot of positive feedback about the store, and has collected ideas from riders about what to sell next.
Bureaucracy
Fundamentally, this is a fun, scrappy idea that needs a nimble implementation, tapped into a community of enthusiasts. Instead, it was administered through a full request for proposals, in the standard bureaucratic procurement flow. That's not something local artists could reasonably take part in.
The city wanted an off-the-shelf solution that minimizes risk. But by minimizing risk, it created the conditions to guarantee something bland, inoffensive and forgettable.
Maybe they should have taken a look at the mural downtown.
It didn't have to be this way
I've been a huge fan of the idea of ETS merch for years. Transit merch is hyper-local. It's a weird little in-group thing that lets people celebrate something quintessentially Edmontonian.
And we're nearly two years into a trade war. Canadians are still buying Canadian on purpose. A city-branded store selling transit gear should have "Proudly made in Canada" as its first line. That should have been table stakes, not a discussion.
Local people are already doing this work. @littledessertspoonshop makes magpie Arc card stickers that are so Edmontonian it hurts. Edmonton Transit Riders volunteers build live transit arrival boards for homes and cafés. Mayor Sohi's office put out an absolutely rad transit shirt last term.
Elsewhere, cities are getting this right. New York City's World Cup jerseys this summer were handmade in Brooklyn by a family-owned shop, designed by a local illustrator, and sold for $50.
ETS says this is a starting point. I hope so. The city absolutely has time to pivot and get this right, but what should have been a celebration of local culture by passionate dorks feels more like a cynical, disconnected play without anyone championing it or using it to build community.
Route 4 deserves better.
Get my news and takes in your inbox
Don't let algorithms control whether you see my latest video or article. We don't need to include Mark Zuckerberg in our relationship.
Free. Emails from Troy Pavlek when I publish something new. Unsubscribe any time.
That didn't go through. Try again in a minute, or email [email protected].
You're in. Thanks for subscribing!