Edmonton's sprawl developers want your property taxes to pad their profit margins.
BILD, the developer lobby, is pushing council to open up land south of 41st Avenue. That's so far south, it's basically Red Deer. Nine thousand hectares of brand new suburbs.
The land south of 41 Ave SW, annexed from Leduc County in 2019.
Growth pays for itself
Their pitch is that growth pays for itself. They even wrote a study that says their very great, excellent, no problems plan has no flaws and would bring in $60 million of surplus every year.
Growth should, and does, pay for itself, as the vast majority of the cost to build new areas is passed on to front-end buyers and long-term ratepayers.
The fine print
But read the fine print. It doesn't count renewal.
The annual cost to operate and maintain the roadways comes to just under $14 million. [...] This total does not include renewal, which is a program that offers major rehabilitation and/or rebuilding of roads and sidewalks in all neighbourhoods as normal aging and degradation take place.
Renewal typically takes place decades after the original infrastructure is built, meaning that for the first lifecycle of a new neighbourhood generates significantly more revenue in tax dollars than it requires in maintenance and operations, thereby generating a significant surplus initially.
They tallied up the years before a single road needs repaving, and then they just... stopped counting.
Remember kids: cars are cheap! As long as you don't include gas, maintenance, oil changes, tires, insurance, or any of the, you know, "little incidentals" that definitely aren't making it cripplingly expensive to get around right now.
The whole life cycle
When the city runs these numbers, it runs the whole life cycle of the neighbourhood. Its modelling found that growing out instead of up costs... just a mere three billion dollars more.
That's $3 billion added to your property tax bill.
Developers build it, sell it, profit, and then dash, stiffing you with the bill for the next 50 years.
Let it go to Leduc
The threat being levied here by BILD's CEO, Kalen Anderson (who, it's worth noting, was so passionate about the trucker convoy's message that she donated to them twice) is that if we don't build it, the growth will go to Leduc or Beaumont.
Good. Let it.
Let them raise their taxes to support unsustainable building practices.
The competition of who can rack up the most credit card debt is not one that we want to win.
Get my news and takes in your inbox
Don't let algorithms control whether you see my latest video or article. We don't need to include Mark Zuckerberg in our relationship.
Free. Emails from Troy Pavlek when I publish something new. Unsubscribe any time.
That didn't go through. Try again in a minute, or email [email protected].
You're in. Thanks for subscribing!