Campaign spending is like a trick from a bad birthday magician.

And yeah, okay, I'll explain this one.

A new column from Keith Gerein at the Edmonton Journal looked at the mayoral campaign spending, which was mostly just one dude flashily burning money.

Knack won spending far less than both Cartmell and Walters, and about a third of what Sohi spent last time.

The winning campaign spent $240,000. That's less than 1/6 of the staggering $1.5 million Cartmell burned through when you factor in party money.

Value for dollars

A phone checkout screen: one mayor's chair, total $1,500,000, Pay with Klarna.

Both candidates campaigned on getting value for dollars, but only one of them actually did.

Knack spent a mere $3 per vote, with Cartmell burning 15 bucks for each vote. That jumps up to $24 per vote if you factor in the party money.

It was less a campaign and more a checkout. Mayor's chair, with Klarna.

Money is the trick

It wasn't just the mayor's race though. All across the city, a bunch of the best-funded candidates lost, which is weird because normally in politics money is the trick.

You stuff your magic wand with a pile of cash and

Electorio Win-iosa!

Elected.

Not this time though, because everyone could see the trick he was pulling.

Cartmell didn't just campaign, he suffocated the city in his messaging. He painted the entire city Better Edmonton teal.

A bus shelter ad of Tim Cartmell reading "Look how much money I have!"

He spent more on advertising than Knack spent on his entire campaign.

Voters saw the force. They saw that he was trying to purchase the election. And once they did, every additional dollar spent only convinced them not to sell.

Like the bad birthday magician, once you see how the trick works, the reveal doesn't land.

Sleight of hand

To be clear, you still need money to win. Probably now more than ever. We don't tune into the same mass media anymore, so reaching a thousand tiny audiences takes real resources.

But modern campaigning isn't about spending the most. It's about spending without looking like you're buying something.

You need sleight of hand, subtlety, a little misdirection. Because if voters see you palming that $5,000 developer check and slipping it up your sleeve, trick's over.

If I had to give one piece of advice to a future mayoral candidate, it'd be:

Go binge-watch Penn & Teller's Fool Us.

Get my news and takes in your inbox

Don't let algorithms control whether you see my latest video or article. We don't need to include Mark Zuckerberg in our relationship.

Free. Emails from Troy Pavlek when I publish something new. Unsubscribe any time.

You're in. Thanks for subscribing!